Where Can I Sell My G.I. Joe Toys for Cash?

Where Can I Sell My G.I. Joe Toys for Cash?

An amazing way to make money is to sell your G.I. Joe toys. You are probably thinking, “Where can I sell my G.I. Joe toys?” This post will guide you through everything involved in selling your old toys.

G.I. Joe toys are America’s number one action figures. And buying them from their previous owners is our goal at Wheeljack’s Lab.

In this post, you will find clear and valuable answers to these popular questions:

  • Where can I sell my old, used, vintage, or collectible G.I. Joe toys?
  • Where can I sell my G.I. Joe collection?

Apart from answering these questions, you will also learn the factors you will need to consider before selling your G.I. Joe toys – old, new, used, or vintage.

At Wheeljack’s Lab, we have been buying old action figure toys for years. And we understand the perfect conditions for selling them to new buyers. So, we will share every important detail to help you make informed decisions.

Without much ado, let us get to it.

Sell Your G.I. Joe Toys at Wheeljack's Lab

Are You the Original Owner of Your G.I. Joe Toys Collection?

1984 Hasbro G.I. Joe Cobra Rattler Attack Jet Wild Weasel

Ownership is the first most important thing when thinking about selling G.I Joe toys. If you are the original owner of the old toys, selling them would be a breeze.

This is because you know when you bought the toys, its toy line, where you bought it, and how its package arrived. These little details would speed up the sale process and boost the amount you get in exchange for your toys.

In essence, second-hand G.I. Joe toys or collectibles from a flea market will not do you much good.

Take an Inventory of Your G.I. Joe Toys

Before you can successfully sell your old G.I. Joe toys, you need to find out what toys you have.

  • Arrange your toys according to their categories, sizes, and toy line
  • Ensure that toy accessories and parts are kept intact
  • Record your findings somewhere safe to prepare for other pre-sales procedures

This step requires a lot of care so that you do not accidentally damage any of the toys in the process.

No doubt, you may have kept your old G.I. Joe toys out of sight for many years. Sorting through their packages, even if they are still intact, could cause them to break or crush.

Find out What Your G.I. Joe Toys are Worth

1989 Hasbro G.I. Joe Cobra H.I.S.S. Tank

For everyone who thinks, “Where can I sell my G.I. Joe toys?” one thing is important – the value of the toy. And you can only know your toys’ worth if you know how much they are worth on the market.

So, visit eBay and other platforms where you can find the same G.I. Joe Toys. If you look at the sold listings, you will learn the actual price buyers were willing to spend on each toy.

Are Your G.I. Joe Toys in Excellent Condition?

It is not enough for you to ask, “Where can I sell my used G.I. Joe toys?” or “Where can I sell my old G.I. Joe toys?”

You need to, first, ascertain that your toys meet three major criteria that can give sufficient insight before the selling process begins.

They include:

  1. Old or used toys should have all toy parts and accessories intact. This can increase how much you get during the sale
  2. Broken or damaged toys may reduce the amount you get when you sell. Ensure you note every wear or tear you notice on the toys.
  3. Used or old G.I. Joe toys with their boxes can boost your returns. If opened, you get a good price, and if sealed or in its default packaging, you get the best deal.

How Clean are Your G.I. Joe Toys?

Shoppers and toy collectors have one thing in common – they want clean products. Nobody wants toys that have spent decades in the sun or have been exposed to dust and smoke.

Dirt and particles of any form would dissuade buyers, so you want to address these cleanliness problems before putting up your vintage G.I. Joe toys for sale.

Carefully clean off the dust and watch a guided video on how to fix sunlight or other yellowing problems on toys.  

Do Your Toys Have any Damage from Animals or Pests?

If your answer is yes, do not expect an answer to your question, “Where can I sell my G.I. Joe toys?” Because no toy collector wants old toys that have dogs, other animals, or even pests have destroyed.

It is almost impossible to prevent animals from pulling at toy collections and other lovely playthings. And you cannot always keep bugs and rodents away.

So, if you have any toys which have suffered a harsh reality with animals and pests, get rid of that toy. No collector would buy it.

Wheeljack's Lab Buys G.I. Joe Toy Collections

6 Possible Places Where You Can Sell Your Collectible G.I. Joe Toys

1982 Hasbro G.I. Joe Cobra Version 1 Straight Arm

Wheeljack’s Lab buys collectible G.I. Joe Toys. But before we give you reasons to sell your toys to us, we will show you six possible places where you can sell them.

You will learn the perks and downsides of each of these options. Feel free to choose what suits you best.


Pawnshops are a popular go-to place for selling vintage G.I. Joe toys. And this is because:

  1. The sales process is quick
  2. Selling your toys here is effortless
  3. You do not need to pay any transaction fees.

Nevertheless, pawnshops are known to give the least return you could ever imagine.

Local Auction

To answer your question of “Where can I sell my G.I. Joe old toys?” local auctions come in third. The advantages here are:

  1. You can trust them since they are within your immediate vicinity
  2. And managing the entire sales process is seamless.

Nonetheless, their drawbacks seem to be more.

  1. Sales period takes longer than online and physical toy stores
  2. Transaction fees are largely on the high side
  3. Your return on investment is both uncertain and of little value.

Craigslist and Similar

Here is another popular option for your toy sale. The perks include:

  1. A wide audience to sell to
  2. No transaction fees
  3. ROI is good enough
  4. Good price for toys

Nonetheless, the following demerits may just be a turn-of:

  1. Higher chances of being swindled
  2. Sales take a long time
  3. An in-person meeting is not always secure
  4. You will be risking your online privacy
  5. Can only be enjoyed by people in urban areas
  6. Communication can be excessive.

Online Toy Shops

The perks of selling your collectible G.I. Joe toys to online toy shops are as follows:

  1. The selling process takes little to no time
  2. These shops require no transaction fees
  3. You can save time doing research or having to market the toys by yourself
  4. You know what store to trust, thanks to the Better Business Bureau.

However, the major drawback here is reduced value. Since these online stores need their profit on your toys, they offer you a large percentage while they take what is left.

Local Toy Stores

With local stores that deal in toys, these are the benefits:

  1. No transaction fees
  2. You can walk into a physical store for your transaction
  3. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) has you covered
  4. Little to no time involved in selling your toys
  5. Sales are quick and hitch-free.

Yet, physical stores must also make their profit. So, your returns are reasonably low here.


In terms of buying and selling vintage toys, eBay is great for two main things:

  1. You have a wider range of prospective buyers
  2. You are more likely to get a decent amount for your toys.

But the drawbacks are quite disturbing. See below:

  1. Your chances of being swindled are high
  2. You could never guess how the bidding would turn out
  3. Transaction fees are significantly high
  4. The sales process takes long
  5. You get daily visits from the post office
  6. You are obliged to accept them if they are returned.

Wheeljack’s Lab will Pay You for Your Vintage G.I. Joe Toys

1992 Hasbro G.I. Joe Liquidator

At Wheeljack’s Lab, we know how cumbersome the process of cleaning, organizing, naming, and storing your old G.I. Joe toys can be. That is why we are offering to help you sort out any boxes or collections of toys you may have and buy them off your hands.

We are a popular vintage toy buyer with more than 20 years in the toy retail industry. Three generations in my family have been in this area and we are here to stay. We provide real-time payment and communication plus prepaid shipping and collection pickup when necessary.

You will receive your toy quotes on the same day. And you can rest assured that the new owners of your old toys would love them even as much as you did.

Do you have old and used G.I. Joe toys?

If you have a collection of old and used toys, you can turn those toys into cash. There is no reason to let those old toys collect dust. Contact us today to sell your G.I. Joe toy collection.

Our professional, friendly, and expert staff have decades of experience as collectible toy buyers. If you are ready to sell your collection today, fill out the form below or call us at 888-946-2895.

  • Add chris@wheeljackslab.com to your contacts so you get our reply.
  • Drop files here or
    Accepted file types: jpg, gif, png, jpeg, pdf, doc, docx, xls, xlsx, txt, rtf, heic, Max. file size: 32 MB, Max. files: 32.
      NOTE – Files are still loading while the loading bar is visible. Once all are loaded click submit. Larger files will take longer.
    • Feel free to send us multiple collections! You can combine them all into one submission or multiple submissions. After submitting this form if you would like to submit another simply refresh this page.

    About the Author

    Author: Chris Ingledue 


    Bio: I am the founder and owner of Wheeljack’s Lab pop Culture and Toy Shop. My vision has always been to reunite customers with their favorite childhood toys and pop culture, triggering fond memories, and reigniting their imaginations. Every day, I work in the “lab” where it’s Christmas 365 days a year. I scour the internet, like when we had the Sears Catalog of yesteryear, for the next great treasure. Then, I await the arrival of the postman as if he were Santa Claus himself and helping collectors worldwide with their versions of Christmas. Every day as a vintage toy buyer is an absolute joy!

       Keep up to date with our latest news

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *