Step back to the late 1980s and early 1990s, when the TMNT craze swept across the globe like a tidal wave. During this phenomenon, the action figures that captured the hearts of countless kids and collectors emerged as iconic symbols of nostalgia. The turtles became household names faster than you could say “cowabunga.” You’ll be learning what the most expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles toy is and how they uphold the legacy of the TMNT Franchise.
In the realm of vintage TMNT toys, they encapsulate the spirit of a bygone era. The playful banter and camaraderie of the four pizza-loving brothers are translated into the meticulously crafted plastic forms that adorn collectors’ shelves today. From the sewers of New York City to the playrooms of kids worldwide, these action figures embodied the spirit of adventure and camaraderie. The tactile joy of snapping together the weapons and accessories and the thrill of reenacting epic battles against Shredder and the Foot Clan created a sensory symphony of childhood memories.
As we explore the rich tapestry of vintage TMNT toys, we must recognize their lasting impact on popular culture. The characters, born from the minds of Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird, transcended the comic book pages to become a multimedia sensation. The toys, an integral part of this phenomenon, not only fueled the animated series and movies but also embedded themselves into the collective consciousness of a generation. In the quest for these relics of the past, collectors find more than just pieces of molded plastic; they rediscover the tangible links to cherished memories, a testament to the enduring legacy of TMNT and the toys that defined an era. So, join us on an intriguing journey through TMNT collectibles, exploring the most expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles toy and its runner-ups.
10. Graded 85 TMNT Slam Dunkin Don
In the world of collectibles, a standout gem emerges: the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles AFA graded 85 Slam Dunkin Don White Jersey Michael Jordan variant. This rare piece boasts Near Mint Condition and a unique twist, making it a must-have for enthusiasts. What sets this particular figure apart is its crossover with basketball legend Michael Jordan, dressed in a distinctive white jersey. The significance of this variant lies in its rarity, capturing the attention of collectors worldwide.
This coveted Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles figure achieved remarkable acclaim, selling for $3,000.00 on December 13, 2018. The price tag reflects the scarcity and desirability of this exclusive variant, as collectors eagerly vied for the chance to own a piece of pop culture history. The active bidding and eventual high sale point highlight the allure of unique, well-preserved items that bridge the worlds of iconic franchises and legendary sports figures.
9. Graded Splinter Soft Head Fan Club Flyer
In the realm of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles collectibles, one rare gem stands out: the highest-graded Splinter soft-head variant that exists! This remarkable find hails from 1988, belonging to the incredibly scarce 1/10 Back Splinter with a soft head. Notably, it comes with a captivating twist, an error in the form of Shredder weapons and accessories. This rarity, coveted by serious TMNT collectors, is a realization of its scarcity, with only two confirmed instances of soft head Splinter with Shredder weapons versions known to exist. On February 25, 2018, the collectible found a new home, fetching an impressive $3,495.00 in a sale that stressed its desirability among avid enthusiasts.
This extraordinary piece, adorned with the prestigious AFA 85 grade, promises rarity and pristine quality. This Splinter variant’s limited availability and unique features make it a prized addition to any toy collection. With whispers circulating about its scarcity, this exclusive TMNT collectible will become a cherished centerpiece in the collection of the fortunate individual who secured it.
8. Graded Raphael Fan Club Flyer Soft Head
The elusive TMNT Raphael fan club flyer with a soft head was graded at 85 by AFA. This particular piece is extraordinary because of its remarkable condition, a true gem for collectors seeking pristine finds. The sub-grades further accentuate its excellence, with an 85 each for the card, bubble, and figure. The custom acrylic case, a recent addition, ensures the safeguarding of this rare piece, presenting it without a hint of wear or damage. Finding such a well-preserved item in this condition is challenging, making this Raphael a standout treasure for discerning collectors.
In a significant transaction on December 23, 2022, this hard-to-find TMNT collectible was bought for an impressive $3,499.99. The price tag reflects not only the scarcity of this particular variant but also the premium placed on its exceptional condition. The clear and fully sealed bubble, free from any dents, adds to its allure. The sale spotlights collectors’ avid interest and willingness to invest in meticulously preserved and rare Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles pieces, solidifying the importance of this Raphael in TMNT memorabilia.
7. TMNT Undercover Raphael
Discover the extraordinary value encapsulated in the Undercover Raphael, preserved in its sealed card packaging, a find that beckons attention. The sealed card not only safeguards the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles collectible but also adds an aura of rarity, accentuating its significance for avid collectors. This unique item boasts three weapons in a striking ocean blue, enhancing its visual appeal and adding a layer of exclusivity. The puncture at the top, which once hung on display shelves for customers to peruse and purchase, is a silent testament to its journey through time and the hands it might have passed through. An authenticating price tag at the top left further solidifies its historical authenticity and validates its place as a sought-after piece in the TMNT memorabilia landscape.
In a recent transaction on April 14, 2023, this Undercover Raphael, with its sealed card and distinctive features, changed hands for a substantial sum of $4,300.00. The price tag reflects the rarity of this particular variant. It emphasizes the premium placed on its sealed condition and unique attributes. As collectors eagerly competed for ownership, the sale speaks to the enthusiasm surrounding well-preserved, distinctive pieces in the expansive world of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles collectibles.
6. Graded Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Party Wagon Van
Delve into the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles world with the 1988 Party Wagon Van, a paramount piece in the TMNT collectibles realm. Graded at an impressive AFA 85, this example stands as the highest-graded version known to exist, adding an exceptional allure for collectors seeking quality. Preserved meticulously, the Party Wagon remains encased in its AFA protective bag. This untouched relic has never experienced removal since its inception. Though some minor shelf wear graces the corners and ends, this detail merely hints at the passage of time, contributing to the authentic charm of this coveted item.
In a notable transaction on March 22, 2023, this remarkable Party Wagon Van found a new home, costing $5,000.00. The sale price speaks volumes about the rarity and significance attributed to this high-graded example. Collectors, eager to secure a piece that stands as the epitome of preservation and rarity, drove the competitive bidding, stressing the enduring appeal of iconic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles memorabilia.
5. Signed TMNT Black & White – 2008 NECA SDCC
Immerse yourself in the rarity of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Black & White 4-figure set from 2008, an exclusive gem from the San Diego Comic-Con by NECA. Elevating its significance, the front of the box bears the distinctive signature and sketch of Co-Creator Kevin Eastman, adding a personalized touch to this already-exclusive set. Notably, the package includes a 4 x 6 double-sided card signed and sketched by Co-Creator Peter Laird and the original autograph ticket that facilitated Eastman’s signature on the box. The completeness of this set, including figures, postcards, and autograph cards, marks it as a scarce find, with the Laird Autograph card standing out as a rarity. The collector’s dream is encapsulated in this set, acquired by the original owner at the 2008 SDCC, and preserved in its unopened state.
In a significant transaction on December 4, 2022, this unparalleled Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set was sold for a substantial $5,000.00. The sale price highlights the immense value attached to this complete and signed ensemble. The prospect of encountering another complete set, adorned with the unique signatures and sketches of both Co-Creators, remains uncertain, making this acquisition a rare and potentially one-of-a-kind addition, cementing itself in fifth place for the most expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles toy.
4. TMNT Brand New Technodrome
Delve into the coveted realm of 1990s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles with the Technodrome set, a pristine piece that captivates collectors with its brand-new status. This item not only represents a nostalgic journey to the heyday of TMNT but also holds intrinsic value as unopened, preserving the magic of that era. The Technodrome, an iconic villainous lair, symbolizes the Turtles’ adventures, encapsulating the essence of the beloved series in its unblemished, factory-sealed state.
In a transaction on July 21, 2023, this pristine Technodrome set was bought for $5,400.00. The sale price speaks volumes about the enduring allure of this classic TMNT piece and the eagerness of collectors to acquire a bit of nostalgia in mint condition. The unopened status of these figures contributes to their rarity. It highlights the unwavering demand for well-preserved Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles memorabilia. This acquisition marks not just a transaction but into the past, allowing collectors to possess a tangible piece of the iconic 1990s TMNT era.
3. Graded Gracie O’Neil No Stripe Fan Club Flyer
Embark on a journey into unparalleled rarity with the sole existing TMNT Series 1/10 Back soft head/fan club/no stripe April O’Neil from 1988. This remarkable piece stands out as an exceptional find, characterized by its unpunched state and the absence of the stripe, signifying its uniqueness. This immaculate collectible has never graced a store shelf, ensuring the lack of a price sticker and preserving its pristine condition. Graded at an outstanding AFA highest 90, meaning near mint, with sub-grades of 90 for the card, bubble, and figure, this April O’Neil exemplifies the epitome of quality, making it a captivating addition to any discerning toy collection.
In a significant transaction on April 13, 2018, this extraordinary TMNT collectible was purchased for an impressive $5,500.00. The sale price reflects the scarcity and distinctiveness of this unique April O’Neil variant. It emphasizes the premium placed on its unparalleled condition. For collectors, this acquisition represents more than just a toy; it symbolizes a rare opportunity to possess a one-of-a-kind piece that stands as a testament to the richness of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ history.
2. Brand New TMNT Scratch the Cat
The incredibly rare Scratch the Cat Figure from Playmates is a coveted piece from 1993 that holds immense importance for collectors. This figure, obtained at Walmart upon its initial release in 1993, stands as a singular discovery, marking the only instance of its sighting in the wild. Sourced from the personal collection of a dedicated TMNT enthusiast, this Scratch the Cat Figure has been meticulously stored, ensuring its pristine condition. The unpunched card, devoid of any visible damage such as creases or bent corners, emphasizes its exceptional preservation. This rare find, encased in a plastic bubble free from dents, emanates from a collector’s smoke and pet-free home, promising an addition of unparalleled rarity to any TMNT collection.
In a landmark transaction on May 9, 2023, this holy grail, Scratch the Cat Figure, changed hands for an impressive $5,999.00. The sale price accentuates the rarity and desirability of this figure, highlighting the anticipation and enthusiasm among collectors seeking a unique and flawless addition to their Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles collection. The assurance of an extraordinary find, coupled with the figure’s impeccable condition and scarcity in the broader market, positions it as the runner-up for the most expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles toy ever sold.
1. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Graded Giant Slam Dunk Don
The sealed 1991 Giant Slam Dunkin’ Don is an ultra-rare holy grail that recently found its way to the market. This masterpiece, sealed to perfection, captures the imagination and is adorned with the prestigious Collector Archive Services (CAS) documentation, providing an extra layer of authenticity. As a top-tier grail piece, it possesses the allure to be the crown jewel and show-stopping centerpiece in even the most impressive collections, promising a visual spectacle that resonates with collectors seeking the epitome of rarity and excellence.
In a monumental transaction on May 29, 2023, this treasure trove of a collectible, the Sealed CAS Grade 80 1991 Giant Slam Dunkin’ Don, was purchased for a galactic sum of $6,000.00. The sale price shows the importance placed on this ultra-rare Holy Grail, deserving itself of the title of the most expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles toy of all time. With its sealed state, high-grade certification, and Collector Archive Services documentation, this Giant Slam Dunkin’ Don affirms its position as a sought-after relic, destined to leave a lasting legacy in the illustrious world of collectibles.
Do You Have Old or Used TMNT Toys?
If you have a collection of old and used toys, you can turn those toys into cash. There is no reason to let those old toys collect dust. Contact us today to sell your TMNT toy collection.
Our professional, friendly, and expert staff have decades of experience as collectible toy buyers. If you are ready to sell your collection today, fill out the form below or call us at 888-946-2895.
About the Owner
Owner: Chris Ingledue
Contact: email
Bio: I am the founder and owner of Wheeljack’s Lab Pop Culture and Toy Shop. My vision has always been to reunite customers with their favorite childhood toys and pop culture, triggering fond memories and reigniting their imaginations. Every day, I work in the “lab,” where it’s Christmas 365 days a year. I scour the internet, like when we had the Sears Catalog of yesteryear, for the next great treasure. Then, I await the arrival of the postman as if he were Santa Claus himself and helping collectors worldwide with their versions of Christmas. Every day as a vintage toy buyer is an absolute joy!