Where Can I Sell Star Wars Toys? How to get the best value for your toys

Old and Used Kenner Star Wars Toys

When you are wondering where and how to sell Star Wars toys, you also want to know how to get the best value out of your sale. Getting the greatest sale price with the least hassle is not an easy task. You need to spend time researching and testing your options when you are selling on your own. Luckily, you do not need to sell your toys without guidance.

You also do not need to look further for advice on how to sell your Star Wars toys for the best value. That is what we do best. As an experienced company in the industry, we wish to keep you informed about your options before you sell your toys to us. You will learn about the different options available to you when it comes to selling your old collection, how to prepare the collection and the pros and cons associated with each option. Where can I sell my Star Wars vintage toys? Let us start you on your path.

Here are some tips to consider before selling your old Star Wars toys

Before selling your toys, you must take care of a few crucial steps. If you are not prepared, you will receive less money.

Who was the original owner of your collection?

We will tell it like it is you will have an easier time selling your old toys if you are the original owner.

 Even if you acquired your collection second-hand or from a flea market, this guide would not be much help to you. Original toys give you a unique insight into how and from when each toy purchase occurred, what goodies came along with the toy, and what line each toy was from. These bits of information significantly affect the final sale price of your Star Wars toys.

For anyone who is not the original owner, we recommend reaching out to us directly for help.

Organizing and identifying your Star Wars collection

As a first step, keep in mind that you must take precautions to prevent your toys from being damaged. Despite being in excellent condition, they may have sat around in storage for decades. So, if you mishandle your old Star Wars toys, they could break.

Sort your complete collection into categories such as toy line, size, and so on. Organizing and cataloging your materials will help you perform the next step. If you have any pieces and accessories, keep them with the toy they belong to.

Research toy prices

Here is a tip for how you can find out how much your collectible Star Wars toys are worth: price your toys first before selling them. On platforms like eBay, you can find the same toy in the same condition. Consider the listing prices of the “sold” listings to get an idea of what people had to pay.

Check the condition of your Star Wars Toys

You want the best possible sales price when you venture out to sell your Star Wars toys. To determine whether your return will be fruitful, every toy in your collection must be in good condition. The following four factors can aid you in making this decision:

The box: Is it included? The box increases the value of the product even if you have an open box.

Sealing: This ties into the box part. You can get a better return on your toy if it is in a sealed box and in factory condition.

Damage: Kids break their toys, and even small breaks can make them worth less than what they can expect. Make sure you take note of any damage or wear.

The Parts: Toys often come with accessories and tiny parts, ensuring you have all those with your toy. 

These are the factors that are often broad, but they can provide an idea of what you should expect. 

Cleanliness of the toy

Collectors are like shoppers. They will not want yellowed toys from cigarette smoke, damage from the sunlight, or caked in dust. However, you can clean some of the most common issues. Just a gentle dusting will remove the dust, and you can remove the damage from sunlight and cigarettes by following a tutorial

How pests and animal damage ruin the value of your Star Wars toys

If you are thinking: where and how can I sell my Star Wars toys? Then the answer is easy. Remember back when you had your favorite doll or action figure and your new puppy drug it off, and when you got it back, it was never the same.

The same goes for collectors. They do not want to purchase toys that have damage. They also do not want toys damaged by pests like mice chewing on them or leaving their droppings everywhere on the toy or bugs getting into the toys and other stuff. If you notice damage like that, then you need to remove them from your collection. 

Where can I sell my old and used Star Wars toys?

We would be interested in buying them, first and foremost. It would be best to consider your options before you decide to sell your collection with nostalgia and all. Our goal is to list those alternatives in this article, and then we will provide you with a complete overview of their pros and cons. There is no right way to go about it. Do what works for you.

Local Auction Service


When it comes to a local auction service, they are often local businesses and easy to use. 


However, using a local auction service provides poor results unless it is an extensive collection. Then you are working with a specialist, and there are only a few in the United States. The sales price is unknown, and it is based on who shows up to the auction, then there are high fees and a slow turnaround time to deal with. 



Pawnshops are often local businesses and are easy to go to. 


When going through a pawnshop, you often will not get the total value of the toy, and they toss you small numbers so that they will not lose out on money. They do not offer a high percentage of money because often, you need the cash now. 

Local Toy Dealer


A local toy dealer will be local and have no fees. You can also run a background check through the Better Business Bureau. They lower the time you spend trying to find a way to sell your toy and have a fast turnaround time. 


Local toy dealers will not give you total value because they do not offer what the toys are worth. If you show up with multiple boxes of toys, you will not get what you want because they know you will not want to box everything back up. 

Online Auctions like eBay


Online auctions offer you the opportunity to connect with a massive network of people. The high volume of collectors seeking out the following best catch often attributes to the soaring prices of toys that sell on eBay. So, you have a great chance to get the highest price available when you sell your Star Wars toys at an online auction.


Since you must describe your Star Wars toys, and bids must come in, this part takes the longest. You must box and ship the toys for every sale. So, if you sell an enormous collection on eBay, expect to make daily trips to the post office. Also, commission fees apply. If you pay a reserve price, you will know what the final bid will be.

Online Classified Websites


Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace are among the very popular online classified sites. Listing is free and straightforward. With this method as well, you will get decent rates.


Still, you must photograph and describe the Star Wars toys that you post about. There may be a long turnaround time since you must wait for an interested person, and you may receive messages from people who have questions but have no intention of buying. 

Online Toy Dealer


It is possible to speed up turnaround time and reduce the amount of time spent on the process. In most cases, we send out quotes within a day of receiving your e-mail. Then, we complete our orders within one week. BBB’s website lets you perform a background check. Best of all, there are no fees involved, and we will cover your shipping costs.


As with any business, we cannot pay the total value.

Wheeljack’s Lab Will Buy Vintage Star Wars Toys for Cash Today 

Starting to sell your Star Wars toys is quite time-consuming, especially if you have never done it before. After cleaning, staging, lighting, and naming, it is time to match everything up. Please call 888-946-2895 if you have an old box of toys that you are ready to sell, or send us a message, and we will take care of everything.

Founded in 1992, Wheeljack’s Lab is known as a well-known vintage toy buyer. Our commitment to being there for you is unwavering. Our family has run this business for three generations! With us, communication is fast, payments are immediate, and shipping is free. We may pick up your collection depending on its size and value. We can provide a quote for your old Star Wars toys on the same day.

About the author

Author: Chris Ingledue 


Bio: I am the founder and owner of Wheeljack’s Lab pop Culture and Toy Shop. My vision has always been to reunite customers with their favorite childhood toys and pop culture, triggering fond memories, and reigniting their imaginations. Every day, I work in the “lab” where it’s Christmas 365 days a year. I scour the internet, like when we had the Sears Catalog of yesteryear, for the next great treasure. Then, I await the arrival of the postman as if he were Santa Claus himself and helping collectors worldwide with their own versions of Christmas. Every day as a vintage toy buyer is an absolute joy!

Do you have old and used Star Wars toys?

If you have a collection of old and used toys, you can turn those toys into cash. There is no reason to let those old toys collect dust. Contact us today to sell your Star Wars toy collection.

When you are looking for the best place to sell your Star Wars toys to, you can not do any better than Wheeljack’s Lab. We have both the experience and the service to ease the sale of your old and used toys. If you are not yet convinced, just look at only a small sampling of the Star Wars toys that we have sold and bought:

Where Can I Sell Star Wars Toys? How to get the best value for your toys
Article Name
Where Can I Sell Star Wars Toys? How to get the best value for your toys
Where can I sell my Star Wars toys to get the best value out there? Get expert advice in this comprehensive guide on selling your toys.
Publisher Name
Wheeljack's Lab
Publisher Logo

   Keep up to date with our latest news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *