Where Can I Sell My GI Joe Toys for Cash?

Ready to sell your G.I. Joe collection?

Do not take the question of “where can I sell my GI Joe toys” lightly. While there are many options available on the market, not every place will give you the same level of treatment for your money.

People tend to sell their old toy collection for money for varied reasons. Sometimes, it is to declutter the house, and other times, it is to raise enough money to buy new ones. Whatever reason you are selling your old toy, we are here to help. Rather than spending all day looking for who buys GI Joe toys, you can easily sell to us.

We have built a sterling reputation over the years as the go-to buyer for toys from top brands, including Hasbro, Duke, Scarlett, Snake Eyes, Transformers, He-Man and even G.I. Read on as we help you understand the sales process, from valuing your old toys to knowing who buys GI Joe toys for cash.

Before setting out to sell your GI Joe collection:

Are you the original owner of the toys?

One important question we ask potential sellers is about the ownership of the toys. If you are selling your toys, the process is quite seamless. But if you are not the original owner, selling might be difficult, especially if the collection is large and includes different toy lines. In that case, we will recommend that you reach out to us via email, and we will take it from there.

Can you identify and sort your collection?

Organizing your collection to differentiate between what is valuable and what is worthless can be tricky. Therefore, you must be cautious. The first step is to group your toys according to the brands. So, if you have a mix of Snake Eyes, Roadblock, Scarlett, Cobra Commander, Duke, and Hasbro figures in your collection, you should sort them according to the brand type. You should not have a problem sorting by toy brands, especially if you are the original owner.

Can you estimate the value of your vintage toys?

Another thing to do before looking for who buys vintage GI Joe toys is to evaluate their worth. Pricing your toys right is an important aspect of the sales process. You can do this by checking out a comparable item that sellers on eBay, or another site, recently sold.

For instance, platforms like eBay allow you to compare prices. But while at it, you should not use the active listings. This is because listings are just what prospective buyers ask for, which they may never get in most cases.

Instead, focus on the sold prices. Scroll through the sold prices until you get to the highest sold price. Do not be surprised if you see identical items or toys that netted final prices of $15 or $25 and $50, or even $100 in some cases. The reason behind this is simple – people pay higher for items they perceive to be nicer and more quality.

Buyers will find it easier to pay higher if an item is mildly used, complete with parts, or still retains its package. All these factors influence the selling price. Although you may not be able to accurately figure out the condition of a toy, you will still get a general idea of its worth.

Is your collection clean?

No one wants a mugged collection. Some buyers prefer that, but it is basically because they get to pay ridiculous money for such collections. You may struggle to find who buys old GI Joe toys that mice, bugs, or pets have damaged and deformed.

Another reason your collection might not be clean is the storage. If you have an item sitting in an open box for an exceedingly long time, for instance, 30 years, chances are that dust now covers the toys. Likewise, vintage GI Joe toys from a smoking home will not be in pristine shape. The smoke will discolor the plastic of the toys, which in turn will make them valued for less. Toys exposed to sunlight while in storage will also suffer discoloration and become weakened, because sunlight breaks down plastic. High heat also deforms the plastic, making them weak and sticky. Low humidity is also not good for stored vintage GI Joe toys.

Fortunately, as a collector, you can fix the yellowing or fading of your toys. We have prepared a guide to help you with restoring your yellowed toys.

Who buys collectible GI Joe toys?

You have a lot of options to choose from when looking for who buys used GI Joe toys. While we have supplied several of such options below (including their pros and cons), you are still expected to choose the possibility that works best for you. You should consider two crucial factors before deciding – how quickly do you want this done and how much time you can spare for the sale of every item in your collection.

That said, let us consider the most popular methods of selling your GI Joe toys for cash.

Local Auction Service

If you prefer to sell your toys at a local location, you should opt for the local auction service. It is also simple and requires less effort. However, you should be ready to deal with the awfully slow turnaround time and high fees. You also cannot decide the sales price – it all depends on who shows up to buy GI Joe toys for cash on the day of the auction.

Lastly, do not expect impressive returns from your sales through this method, especially if your collection is small and you are not working with a specialist.


Pawnshops are also local, so they are easily accessible and require minimal effort. But you will miss out on the full value for your items since you are dealing with a captive audience who knows you need cash urgently. Most Pawnshop owners or attendants are not experts, so they tend to value your collection at ridiculous rates. They just want to make sure they are not on the losing end of the transaction.

Online Toy Dealer

Online toy dealers are one of your best options when looking for who buys collectible GI Joe toys. The process is faster – we could complete the whole sale process in less than a week. These dealers do not charge you for anything whatsoever. If you are lucky, they might even cover the shipping fees. They are also verifiable with the Better Business Bureau. However, all of these come at the expense of getting full value for your collections.

Local Toy Dealers

Local toy dealers offer all the same advantages as online toy dealers. They simplify and speed up the process and charge no fee. They are also local and verifiable with the Better Business Bureau. But they know you are a captive audience, so they offer a low percentage just like the pawnshop. You may go with 10 boxes of toys and get below what you should in terms of value.

Online Auctions, such as eBay

Online auctions offer you access to a large client base, which translates to competitive prices. But that is just the good part; you still must contend with the complicated, slow, demanding, and unreliable process. Looking for who buys old GI Joe toys on online auctions puts you at the risk of fraud because you must accept returns. You are also uncertain about the bidding process.

Online Swap Pages on Craigslist and Facebook

The biggest benefit of using swap pages on the internet to find who buys GI Joe toys include access to decent prices and a large client base. These platforms are free and quite easy to use. But that said, you might not get things done fast. The entire process is time-consuming and slow. You are also at the risk of serious fraud and privacy concerns. There is no customer support to help you with issues, and you might spend all day talking to tire-kickers who have no intention of buying your collectible GI Joe toys.

Wheeljack’s Lab can and will buy your GI Joe Toys for Cash

First-timers will have a challenging time selling their old GI Joe toys for cash. You must clean, stage, light, name, and even match all the items before you can turn your collection into cash. Do you have a collection of GI Joe toys you want to sell? Be it new toys, used toys, old toys, or vintage toys, we will be glad to buy them at Wheeljack’s Lab. All you must do is call us at 888-946-2895 or send a message, and we will take it from there.

With several years of industry experience buying and selling vintage toys, we know how to make the complete process seamless for you. It is a generational business dedicated to helping people get the best value for their old toys. With us, you can rest assured of excellent and prompt communications, immediate payments, and even prepaid shipping.

When necessary, we may pick up your collection and provide you with same-day quotes. Your quest to find out who buys GI Joe collectible toys for cash ends here. Trust us to get new and befitting homes for your old toys.

Author: Chris Ingledue 


Bio: I am the founder and owner of Wheeljack’s Lab pop Culture and Toy Shop. My vision has always been to reunite customers with their favorite childhood toys and pop culture, triggering fond memories, and reigniting their imaginations. Every day, I work in the “lab” where it’s Christmas 365 days a year. I scour the internet, like when we had the Sears Catalog of yesteryear, for the next great treasure. Then, I await the arrival of the postman as if he were Santa Claus himself and helping collectors worldwide with their own versions of Christmas. Every day as a vintage toy buyer is an absolute joy!

Ready to sell your GI Joe Toys? Wheeljack’s Lab is your best choice!

Wheeljack’s Lab has been buying and selling GI Joe toys for decades. We have the knowledge, understanding, and experience to get you the best price and service for your collection.

Just look at only a small sample of the GI Joe toys that have been sold through Wheeljack’s Lab!

Where Can I Sell My GI Joe Toys for Cash?
Article Name
Where Can I Sell My GI Joe Toys for Cash?
Do not take the question of "Where can I sell my GI Joe Toys" lightly. Read this article before you make a costly mistake!
Publisher Name
Wheeljack's Lab
Publisher Logo

   Keep up to date with our latest news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *